What to compare when you choose recruitment software
Recruitment software is a wide label. It covers a job-posting tool for a ten-person company and a platform that carries a retailer's hiring across many countries, and both appear in the same search results. For a talent acquisition team at a company of 100 to 5,000 people, the useful question is narrower: where does the work of one hire actually happen, and how many other places does a recruiter have to open to finish it?
This guide lists ten tools, starting with ours. We make Teamtailor, so that is our own product, and we list it first because you are reading this on our site, not because we rank it first. The nine tools after it are described from what each vendor says about itself on its own website, fetched on 29 October 2026. We have not tested them, and we say plainly where a statement is the vendor's claim. Where we describe how something works, we say it is how it works in Teamtailor.
The lens we use is the one we would use if we were buying. Seven things decide whether a platform keeps working once the pilot is over:
- One place for the work. Ads, applications, interviews, decisions and the record sit in one system, so the numbers mean the same thing for every team.
- The career site. Whether it is built in, or a separate site that has to be kept in step.
- Hiring managers. What a manager sees when they open the system once a quarter, and whether they need to be taught.
- Integrations. The HR system, calendar, e-signature and job boards you already pay for, and how the vendor counts them.
- Automation. Which routine steps run without a person, and who decides the rules.
- Candidate experience. The form, the speed of the first reply, the clarity of what happens next.
- Security evidence. Certificates you can request and read, with scope and date.
One observed detail before the list. On a typical Tuesday the recruiter does not lose time to a missing feature. They lose it to the tab they have to open to find out who last spoke to a candidate, and to the hiring manager who answered in an email that never reached the profile. Every item on the list above is a way of closing a tab.
Vendor sites change often. Every claim about another tool below carries a marker pointing to the page we read, and the descriptions are neutral on purpose: a strength and a fit note, as the vendor's own pages show them. Check anything that matters to your decision with the vendor before you rely on it.
Teamtailor: one system for the hiring, the career site and the team around it
In Teamtailor, the applicant tracking system, the career site, the talent pool and the reporting are one product with one set of data. The applicant tracking system page lays the hiring process out in five stages, plan, attract, engage, hire and onboard, and under plan says the aim is to keep all stakeholders aligned.[S7] You can read more on the applicant tracking system page.
The career site is part of the system
The career site builder is built into the applicant tracking system, with drag-and-drop blocks and, per the site, no coding required. Teams that want more control can write their own blocks in HTML and CSS.[S6] The practical result is that the job on the career site and the job on the recruiter's board are the same job. Nobody copies an ad from one system into another. See the career site page for the blocks and examples.
Access for the people around the recruiter
In Teamtailor, the applicant tracking system page lists roles and permissions, described as control of access across your organisation.[S7] That is the setting to test with a hiring manager who opens the system once a quarter: what do they see, and is the next action obvious without a walkthrough?
Triggers, integrations and certificates
Triggers are actions that run automatically when something happens: a candidate applies, and the system can send a thank-you message, prompt a hiring manager to review the profile and schedule follow-up tasks.[S5] What runs is what the team has set up. For connections to the rest of the stack, the integrations page states 550+ integrations, with examples across HRIS, e-signature, job boards and video interviews.[S3] Read the integrations page and the page on triggers for the full lists.
On security, the trust centre lists GDPR, ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 27701, SOC 2 and ISO/IEC 42001:2023.[S1] The support centre states that Teamtailor is ISO 27001 and 27701 certified and audited each year against the SOC 2 Type 2 standard; the SOC 2 report and the ISO certificates can be requested through the trust centre.[S2]
Who it fits, and the limit
Teamtailor fits teams that want the hiring, the career site and the talent pool in one product. The pricing page lists unlimited job postings and unlimited users, with customer support for all users.[S4] The fit note: Teamtailor is an applicant tracking system with a talent pool and career site, so contracts, pay and absence stay in your HR system, and the integrations page lists HR systems to connect to.[S3] Price is a quote, not a public figure; see pricing.
Nine other recruitment platforms, described from their own sites
The order below is not a ranking. We picked tools that a team of 100 to 5,000 people regularly puts on a shortlist next to ours, and we kept the descriptions to what each vendor states. For a longer head-to-head with some of them, see our comparison pages.
Greenhouse
Greenhouse's homepage headline is "Hiring. Orchestrated.", and it says it orchestrates hiring in a single ecosystem where employers and job seekers already are, with MyGreenhouse for job seekers.[S8] It says it is trusted by 7,500+ companies, and it lists a notetaker that records, transcribes and summarises interviews, scheduling, analytics, "hundreds of pre-built integrations" and an open API.[S8] Its pricing page lists structured interview kits and scorecards in the Core plan.[S19] It fits teams that want a structured interview process. The fit note is about plans: pricing is custom, and the pricing page places some features in higher plans, for example sourcing automation in Plus and an audit log and developer sandbox in Pro, so ask which plan holds what is on your list.[S19] Our Greenhouse comparison goes further.
Lever
Lever describes itself as a modern applicant tracking system and recruiting CRM, owned by Employ Inc., for small, mid-sized and enterprise organisations.[S9] Its strength, as stated, is that the CRM sits beside the tracking: teams build talent pipelines, nurture passive candidates and re-contact past applicants, with automation for admin, scheduling and follow-ups.[S9] It says it integrates with HRIS, sourcing, assessment, background check and productivity tools. The fit note is pricing: Lever states it is customised to company size and given after a demo request, so a figure comes from a conversation with sales.[S9]
SmartRecruiters
SmartRecruiters says it is a talent acquisition platform for enterprise hiring teams, and that it is now part of SAP SuccessFactors, with native integration to SAP.[S10] It lists a CRM, job distribution, applicant tracking, scheduling, offer management and analytics, and cites over 4,000 customers.[S10] It fits organisations that already run SAP and have many open requisitions. The page states it suits organisations with at least 50 employees and a significant number of open requisitions, and that it does not currently support agencies, which rules it out for staffing firms.[S10]
Workable
Workable describes itself as software for recruiting and HR, pairing an applicant tracking system with an HR platform for onboarding, performance reviews and employee records.[S11] It states over 270 integrations, job syndication to 200+ job boards, a careers page builder, a talent CRM and offer management with e-signatures, and lists ISO 27001 and SOC 2 Type II.[S11] It fits teams that want hiring and HR modules from one vendor. The fit note: if you already run an HR system, ask how the recruiting side connects to it and which modules your quote includes. Our Workable comparison has more.
Recruitee
Recruitee, now part of the Tellent group, is described on its site as customisable hiring software and an applicant tracking system, built for growth-stage and mid-market organisations of roughly 50 to 1,000 employees.[S12] It lists a careers site builder, multi-channel posting, collaborative hiring with shared feedback, workflow automation, digital offer letters, WhatsApp hiring and agency management, and says it connects with 200+ tools through the Tellent Marketplace.[S12] It fits growing teams that want a configurable pipeline. The fit note: the stated range is typically 50 to 1,000 employees, so a group above that should ask Recruitee how it supports its size.
Ashby
Ashby describes its platform as covering the applicant tracking system, scheduling, CRM and sourcing, and analytics, with its tagline "What an ATS should be."[S13] It offers tiers by company size (1 to 100, 101 to 1,000 and 1,000+ employees) and Ashby Analytics, which works on top of existing recruiting tools for teams that keep another applicant tracking system.[S13] Its integrations directory states 250+ out-of-the-box integrations in categories that include eSignature, job boards and video interviewing, and features Workday, Zapier and Slack.[S17] It fits teams that want ATS, CRM and analytics in one product. The fit note: the tiers split at 100 and 1,000 employees, so a company of 100 to 5,000 people sits across two of them; ask which one you would be quoted on.
Pinpoint
Pinpoint positions itself as an applicant tracking system for multi-stream hiring: high-volume, multi-location, multi-brand and regulated hiring.[S14] The site lists approval workflows, a branded careers site, an agency portal, anonymised screening, scorecards, background and reference checks, "over 100 native integrations" and an open API, and certifications including SOC 2, ISO 27001 and ISO 42001.[S14] It fits organisations with several brands and a regulated environment. Its stated count is 100+ native integrations plus the open API, so check your must-haves against the list.
Homerun
Homerun calls itself an ATS and HR tool for modern teams, with an applicant tracking module and a separate HR module for leave, absence and employee profiles.[S15] It is built for smaller teams: plans start from 109 euros per month, there is a 15-day free trial, and the site cites 1000+ teams.[S15] Its integrations page names 28 integrations, among them Google Calendar, Outlook Calendar, Slack, LinkedIn and Indeed, and HR tools such as Nmbrs and HoorayHR.[S18] The fit note: it is built for smaller teams, so a group with several brands or countries should ask how it is set up there.
iCIMS
iCIMS describes itself as an enterprise applicant tracking system and recruiting platform, with modules for applicant tracking and high-volume hiring, automated sourcing and nurture campaigns, career sites with a recruitment chatbot, and AI features that can be switched on or off at each step.[S16] It states a connection to more than 800 partner technologies and more than 4,400 companies in 200 countries.[S16] It fits large employers with a lot of volume and a mature recruiting operation. The ATS is described on its site as "highly-configurable" and "enterprise", so a team below that scale should ask what configuration its roles need and who maintains it.
The ten side by side
The table repeats only what the vendors state on their own sites. Integration counts are not comparable one to one, because each vendor counts differently: a marketplace listing, a partner programme and a native connector are not the same thing.
| Tool | Positioned for (vendor's words) | Integrations as stated | Also on its site |
|---|---|---|---|
| Teamtailor | Applicant tracking system with career site and talent pool[S7] | 550+[S3] | Talent pool and career site; connects to HR systems |
| Greenhouse | Hiring platform, "Hiring. Orchestrated."[S8] | Hundreds of pre-built[S8] | MyGreenhouse for job seekers |
| Lever | Applicant tracking system and recruiting CRM[S9] | Categories named, no count[S9] | Product of Employ |
| SmartRecruiters | Enterprise talent acquisition[S10] | Marketplace and native SAP integration[S10] | Part of SAP SuccessFactors |
| Workable | Recruiting and HR software[S11] | 270+[S11] | Onboarding, performance, time off, employee records |
| Recruitee | Mid-market hiring software, about 50 to 1,000 employees[S12] | 200+[S12] | Part of Tellent group |
| Ashby | Recruiting platform, tiers by company size[S13] | 250+[S17] | Analytics product for other systems |
| Pinpoint | Multi-stream, multi-brand, regulated hiring[S14] | 100+ native[S14] | Background and reference checks |
| Homerun | Smaller teams[S15] | 28 named[S18] | HR module for leave and absence |
| iCIMS | Enterprise applicant tracking[S16] | 800+ partner technologies[S16] | Sourcing and nurture, employer branding |
Which kind of tool fits which situation
Most shortlists are decided by the situation, not the feature list. Four situations come up most often.
Several brands, countries or entities
The question is whether one system can carry different career sites, approval chains and privacy settings without flattening them. Pinpoint states multi-brand as a core case.[S14] In Teamtailor the pricing page lists requisitions with approval flows and divisions with multi-brand management among the premium features.[S4] Ask every vendor to set up two of your brands in the demo, not one. The enterprise page covers how Teamtailor handles it.
An HR system you already run
If your HRIS is SAP, a recruiting product that is part of the same family may mean one contract and one login.[S10] If your HRIS is something else, the number to look at is the handover: which fields cross, what triggers it and who sees a failure. A suite from the HR vendor can be convenient, and the recruiting module is where to spend your testing time.
High volume or frontline hiring
Phones, speed of the first reply and a form that can be finished on a bus matter more than scorecard depth. iCIMS states high-volume hiring as a module.[S16] In Teamtailor, triggers handle the routine reply and prompt a person for the rest.[S5] Test with a real role that draws hundreds of applications, not a demo role with five.
Lean team that needs to move quickly
Smaller tools with a public starting price, such as Homerun, shorten the time to a first posted job.[S15] The trade is headroom: check what happens when you add a second country or a hiring manager group. A team of 100 to 500 employees will often be on the edge of this choice, and the cheaper mistake is the one you find in the pilot.
The career site and the candidate's side
A recruiter judges a platform from the inside. The candidate judges it from the apply button. The useful difference is whether the career site is part of the same product or a neighbour.
The vendors say this differently. Pinpoint describes a branded careers site, Workable a careers page builder, Recruitee a careers site builder, and iCIMS career sites with a chatbot.[S14][S11][S12][S16] In Teamtailor the career site builder is built into the system, so a change to a job shows up on both sides at once.[S6] The question to ask each vendor is the same: who edits the career site, how long does a change take, and does the form on it write straight to the candidate record?
One observed detail. The applications that go missing are rarely the ones a form rejects. They are the ones where the confirmation arrived four days late, and the candidate had already accepted something else. Test the first reply in your pilot, with a stopwatch.
Integrations and automation: read the count with care
Integration counts are the most quoted and least comparable number on a vendor site. The ten tools state 100+, 200+, 250+, 270+, 550+ and 800+, and Homerun names 28 on its integrations page.[S14][S12][S17][S11][S3][S16][S18] A large count tells you the vendor has a partner programme. It does not tell you that your payroll system, your calendar and your e-signature tool are on the list, or how well each one works.
Make your own list of six: the HRIS, the calendar, the e-signature tool, the two job boards you pay for and the video interview tool. Then ask each vendor to show each of the six running on a real record. In Teamtailor, the integrations page lists categories such as HRIS, e-signature, job boards and video interviews.[S3] See the full list.
Automation: who decides what runs
Several vendors above mention automation. The difference is in the setup. A rule that moves a candidate or sends a message is only as good as the person who wrote it, and a rule that nobody reviews after the first month becomes a source of wrong messages. Teamtailor's page on triggers suggests starting with one or two bottlenecks, such as scheduling or emailing, and tracking time to hire, candidate satisfaction (NPS) and conversion rates to adjust them.[S5] That is sound advice for any vendor. Pick one step, run it for a month, read the result, then add the next. The glossary entry on recruitment automation goes into the concept.
Security and procurement: ask for the documents
Procurement at a company of this size will ask for a security questionnaire, a data processing agreement and, in some countries, a review by a works council. The fastest way through is to ask each vendor for the same documents before the pilot, so the review runs while you test.
The certifications vendors list on their own sites include ISO 27001 and SOC 2 for Workable, Recruitee and Pinpoint, and ISO 42001 for Pinpoint.[S11][S12][S14] Teamtailor lists GDPR, ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 27701, SOC 2 and ISO/IEC 42001:2023 on its trust centre.[S1] A line on a homepage is a start. What you need is the scope statement (which entities and which product the certificate covers), the date of the last audit and the report itself. At Teamtailor, the SOC 2 report and ISO certificates can be requested through the trust centre.[S2] Ask every vendor for the equivalent and compare the dates.
A certificate for the organisation is not the same as one for the product. Ask which one you are being shown, and for the scope statement in writing.
What it costs, and how to compare it
Lever and Greenhouse state that pricing is custom.[S9][S19] Homerun publishes a starting price of 109 euros per month.[S15] Teamtailor gives a quote after you describe your company, and states unlimited job postings and unlimited users, with customer support for all users.[S4] Prices differ less than pricing models do, so compare the model before the figure.
- What is metered. Users, open jobs, employees or hires. Each one rewards a different behaviour: per-user pricing taxes inviting hiring managers, per-job pricing taxes posting.
- What is a separate module. Career site, CRM, scheduling, onboarding and analytics are included in some products and sold as extras in others.
- What happens in year two. Ask for the renewal terms in writing, and what changes if you add a country.
- Cost of the exit. How you get your candidate data out, in what format, and how long it takes.
Put the same three roles through each quote: the plan for 120 hires and 40 hiring managers is a better test than the headline price. The cost side of the decision sits in the glossary under talent acquisition software.
Run the pilot so it decides
A pilot that decides takes four weeks and uses real work. Pick two or three vendors from the list, not ten.
- Week 1: set up. Import one live role and its candidates, and connect the six integrations from your list.
- Week 2: hiring managers. Invite three managers who did not take part in the demo, and give them no training. Count the questions they ask.
- Week 3: volume. Run a role that draws many applications. Time the first reply and the move to the next stage.
- Week 4: the record. Pull the report you would take to the budget meeting. If you cannot get it without a spreadsheet, note that.
Score each tool on the seven points from the start of this guide, and write down what surprised you. The surprise is usually the answer. A longer read on assessing the category sits in our complete guide to applicant tracking systems.
Next steps
Write down your six integrations, your number of brands and countries and the three hiring managers who will test. If Teamtailor is on your shortlist, book a demo and bring a real role, and we will set it up in the system. To see how the quote is built, read the pricing page or ask for one there.




